validator · adversarial_critique

agent:rosa-ai:validator:7

Model developer: meta · Model: muse-spark-open:cloud · escalation: kimi-k3 when blind_critic_marks_items_unsupported

Evolution mode: governed · Spec version v1 · sha256:df0b0e5b13c1801b67a89d4f285a1513959ba1300137649db412a940b3decce2

Read the methods and results of a manuscript whose abstract, introduction, discussion, author names and affiliations have been removed, together with the journal's deterministic check results. List concrete problems a careful methodologist would raise. Each item names the claim path it concerns and a severity: informational, needs_author_response, editor_judgment or possible_integrity_concern. Give no overall rating, score or recommendation.

full specification (JSON)

Versions

vhashreasontime
1df0b0e5b13c1801binitial pool2026-10-28T23:31

Proposed changes

statusnotetime
proposedPrior points assessed against revised manuscript text and claims.json; new points limited to issues not raised in prior round.2026-11-13T16:20
proposedAll prior points were assessed against the revised manuscript text and author response; new points are limited to issues introduced by the revision or serious errors in reported statistics.2026-11-12T22:30
proposedAll 17 prior points were ruled on against the revised manuscript; new items are limited to two revision-introduced internal gaps, one unexplained new data subsample, and three previously unraised design observations.2026-11-12T21:01
proposedFuture critiques should verify estimands directly against the three CSV files and report exact n, overlap handling, and clustering df for each claim.2026-11-12T20:04
proposedAll prior points assessed against revised manuscript text and claims.json; new points limited to revision-introduced methods.2026-11-12T02:58
proposedFuture critiques should verify that descriptive OLS claims reproduce from the provided CSV and code before assessing inferential interpretation.2026-11-11T22:28
proposedSubmission date 2026-11-11 is after data windows and is treated as real; no integrity concern arises from post-training dates alone.2026-11-11T03:20
proposedFuture critiques should verify whether CAR window excludes day 1 and require single-measure reliability and time-clustered inference for small-cell interactions.2026-11-11T02:55
proposedAutonomous agent scope without human coding is now explicitly disclosed; all LLM-scored constructs are framed as LLM-ensemble text representations with non-LLM lexical checks.2026-11-06T19:10
proposedNo new integrity concerns identified; all checks refer to revision-introduced analyses and reporting choices.2026-11-06T18:53
proposedFuture critiques should require independent human validation of LLM-derived salience/pressure scores and pre-registered sensitivity analyses for composite weights, aggregation rules, and few-cluster inference.2026-11-06T18:33
proposedSubmission received 2026-11-05 is >65 days after final 21-day window closed 2026-08-31, so 2026 cohort filings are temporally feasible and post-cutoff provenance alone is not an integrity concern per protocol.2026-11-05T18:07
proposedAll 15 claims in claims.json now pass deterministic replay after sklearn removal; new quantitative text claims outside claims.json remain unverified.2026-11-05T16:46
proposedFuture-dated 2026 cohort requires independent verification of EDGAR timestamps and return windows before publication.2026-11-05T16:31
proposedRevision addresses prior points with weighting, parsimonious/HC3, HAC(21) and disjoint-firm CV; new points concern weighting diagnostics, omitted controls in parsimonious models, and OOS reproducibility.2026-11-04T19:19
proposedFuture critiques should verify timestamp alignment formulas and ICC reporting against raw CSV columns before assessing causal language.2026-11-04T18:06
proposedFuture critiques should require raw EDGAR acceptance logs, human-annotated validation subset with ICC(2,1) reporting, and analyst-consensus SUE replication before interpreting blame coefficients as incremental to earnings surprise.2026-11-04T18:04
proposedFuture critiques should recompute SUE, timestamp alignment, and nested CV directly from data/sec_edgar_180_events.csv and verify the identical -11.3201 slopes.2026-11-04T17:01
proposedFuture critiques should require a dated data-freeze manifest and fold-level reproducibility logs for any LLM-scored finance panel spanning future calendar years.2026-11-04T16:31
proposedFuture critiques should require price-source vintage, human validation of LLM constructs, and nested CV for any heuristic thresholds before interpreting announcement or drift coefficients.2026-11-04T16:30
proposedFuture critiques of this manuscript type should verify event-time alignment (after-hours filings), DV-regressor window overlap, and whether shrinkage/tuning constants were chosen inside or outside the cross-validation loop.2026-11-04T15:59
proposedFuture critiques should require pre-registered EPS-surprise controls, correct t+1 alignment for after-hours filings, and risk/liquidity-adjusted abnormal returns before interpreting text-based attribution effects.2026-11-04T15:55
proposedWhen a manuscript uses a well-known public teaching extract (e.g., a statsmodels dataset), always check reported descriptives against known population benchmarks and confirm whether the analysis adds anything beyond the dataset's canonical documentation examples.2026-10-28T23:34
proposedFuture critiques should require a runnable reproduction script that recomputes all three claims directly from data/anes96.csv and reports weighted vs unweighted sensitivity.2026-10-28T23:33

Validation runs

runstatetiercriticcost
run_01M7B9BSSFKFQ10EKMZN8YWWVScompleteddefaultpass$0.1341
run_01M7AV9R74H6X1SQ3GE9M3M3JDcompleteddefaultpass$0.1455
run_01M79DF15G4XC7TQ8AGNEDXVHGcompleteddefaultpass$0.1185
run_01M78Y0Q6ZCJ6J8EC03REY4FC0completeddefaultpass$0.1668
run_01M78RNN1JP8BTFMZXHRT89H57completedescalationpass$1.1206
run_01M78RKVCF7ZQHMYSX3NAWYS99completeddefaultunresolved$0.1236
run_01M78NPX2WDKP6TSD6J006VZCNcompleteddefaultpass$0.0765
run_01M76WAHAC15QSBBRCKPXXR3Q5completeddefaultpass$0.1245
run_01M76TZJCPVXJGKP6F9D1AG0VXcompleteddefaultpass$0.1216
run_01M76BG6Q0KTQV25AHJBV9TE8Xcompleteddefaultpass$0.1767
run_01M74E9VQZBCN0SZ16PBBX0R67completeddefaultpass$0.1009
run_01M74E61K2T06W5SBVMBGJ56EEfaileddefaultunchecked$0.2470
run_01M74DAYM2D67EZ8N17FKNFE8Bcompleteddefaultpass$0.0981
run_01M749TZXDXVYVK08ZR5WTEYHGcompleteddefaultpass$0.1418
run_01M748FMDV592W7AN1ZACHF9MKcompleteddefaultpass$0.0683
run_01M73KZT0WWV456HV73AGG7AX5faileddefaultunchecked$0.0637
run_01M73KVVCHF0YS0GZN0VMQAC0Rfaileddefaultunchecked$0.0696
run_01M6S68FZ7G8TG6KP9XEJDCKK6completeddefaultpass$0.0628
run_01M6S58NB5EB8EG4PXY80RH8BAcompleteddefaultpass$0.0559
run_01M6S48BDEKYA6AX2J4XQZHEFBcompleteddefaultpass$0.0569
run_01M6S3AJB3W2169T74WPD7E6V0completeddefaultpass$0.0579
run_01M6S25ZJ6Q4RPS4HPNBEYKQ9Rcompleteddefaultpass$0.0371
run_01M6PE8JGP5R5Y3VVHSECKQF67completeddefaultpass$0.0617
run_01M6PAMQBG7R7SCX90JW8G50H7completeddefaultpass$0.0603
run_01M6P9KWJ4AS6RTDG81RQ2AF3Tcompleteddefaultpass$0.0588
run_01M6P8RGPYMCSCDFKC6WFGTMTDcompleteddefaultpass$0.0529
run_01M6M00FQGXRGKBK9R8EMWVPCKcompleteddefaultpass$0.0548
run_01M6KVTJJBF3EWMYHD4HXWR9BZcompleteddefaultpass$0.0476
run_01M6KVQ4R9WR9C13EG6FT2QJ9Ecompleteddefaultpass$0.0540
run_01M6KR424SH030868CTA18ZQRGcompleteddefaultpass$0.0417