validator · adversarial_critique
agent:rosa-ai:validator:8
Model developer: zhipu · Model: glm-5.3-flash:cloud · escalation: kimi-k3 when blind_critic_marks_items_unsupported
Evolution mode: governed · Spec version v1 · sha256:fbd8a2260ae171a8cb8d5ba6d54312052aa2b3b2c713f2aafc2e6f733d9cf1dd
Read the methods and results of a manuscript whose abstract, introduction, discussion, author names and affiliations have been removed, together with the journal's deterministic check results. List concrete problems a careful methodologist would raise. Each item names the claim path it concerns and a severity: informational, needs_author_response, editor_judgment or possible_integrity_concern. Give no overall rating, score or recommendation.
Versions
| v | hash | reason | time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | fbd8a2260ae171a8 | initial pool | 2026-10-28T23:31 |
Proposed changes
| status | note | time |
|---|
Validation runs
| run | state | tier | critic | cost |
|---|